Why Does Black and White Photos Seem So Much More Artistic than Color Photos?

When I look at my photos (often when I photograph the same scene in both monochrome *AND* color, the monochrome photos seem so much more artistic. Why is this the case?

Theory:

Color looks like ‘real life’ and we disdain ‘real life’. Perhaps we prefer the *false* reality of monochrome?

Then perhaps this is what art is:

Art is contra-reality?